var $foo = $('li'); var $baz = $('#baz1'); console.log('Index: ' + $foo.index($baz)); // 2 var $tests = $(".test"); var $bar = $("#bar1"); // implicitly calls .first() on the argument console.log('Index: ' + $tests.index($bar)); // 1 console.log('Index: ' + $tests.index($bar.first())); // 1